Semi-Private · 27 Holes

Middle Island Country Club

275 Middle Island-Yaphank Road, Middle Island, New York

Semi-PrivateMembership
27Holes
3.9296 Reviews
Middle Island, NYLocation

The Club

About Middle Island Country Club

Middle Island Country Club offers a welcoming environment for golf enthusiasts with its 18-hole course. The club provides online reservations for riding, ensuring a convenient booking experience. Golfers can enjoy the scenic beauty and challenging layout of the course.

Play Here

Green Fees

Weekday 18-hole$60
Weekend/Holiday 18-hole$75

Rates are approximate and from public sources — confirm current pricing with the course.

Facilities

Club Amenities

Motor Cart
Pull Cart
Club Rental
Pro Shop
Golf Lessons
Driving Range
Putting Green
Chipping Green
Practice Bunker
Restaurant
Reception Hall
Changing Room

Real Estate

Nearby Listings

No listings at this club yet — here are nearby properties:

Reviews

What People Say

3.9/5
Google · 296 reviews
In summary

Middle Island Country Club is generally praised for its well-maintained course, lush fairways, and challenging layout across its three nine-hole options, making it a popular choice for many golfers. The staff is often described as friendly and accommodating, and amenities such as the clubhouse and beverage service are appreciated. However, some visitors have experienced slow pace of play and issues with course management, including pricing confusion and overcrowding, which have detracted from their overall experience.

a week ago
The course is generally in good shape. Some of the tee boxes are a little rough but fairways and greens are in really good shape. Sand traps need some new sand. A little rough and rocky. But overall a good day.
— Kevin Fitzpatrick
Edited 5 years ago
Today played 18 holes. This course is beautiful, well maintained, fairways are lush green , nicely groomed, greens are also very good. Overall i loved this course. Staff is very nice and smiling. Beverages cart making rounds non stop. Carts are clean and sanitized. Clubhouse , restrooms are clean, and they have strict mask policy if you enter the Clubhouse. Bar is open and bartender girl is very nice.good collection of wine and hard liquor as well as beers 🍻. Must play course, will be back. 👍
— jaswinder singh
2 years ago
Beautiful course! Very well maintained 27 holes and the starter will divide the groups up accordingly making the pace really good. Conditions are great especially coming from city courses. It’s an hour drive out from queens but definitely feels like an outing rather than typical local courses and blindly going through the motions for 18 holes. Ordered hot dogs and fries/ onion rings during hole 8 then pick up at the bar to eat during back 9. Really recommend this course!!
— Will Park
5 months ago
This golf course is crazy! The reason is the hot deal price is only $54 for walking only, while the regular price including a cart is $67. Please, I beg you, get rid of the hot deal! It's confusing. Golf courses that aren't making money have a reason. Learn from Willow Creek Country Club.
— Kenny Jung
Edited 2 years ago
First time playing this course. Overall, my experience was positive, and I will come back to try the Oak Tree and Spruce track combination. This track is a step up compared to munis like Eisenhower Park. Here are the details of my takeaways of this course: [1] Pace of play: 4 hours and 22 minutes was not the best but barely passable. [2] Course conditions - Tee boxes: Pretty worn out, but still acceptable [3] Course conditions - Fairways: A few wet spots but not too soggy. There were also a few bare spots that I had to move my ball at least twice in my round. [4] Course conditions - Greens:…
— Grint_POY_2025
3 years ago
Great experience here. Pace was excellent during the weekend. Tee boxes , fairways and greens were excellent. People was really nice here too. Will definitely be back!
— G Lee
Edited a year ago
Our go to public course! 3 nine hole courses in good shape. Still improving, latest is small bar/restaurant with a simple menu. Good rates, course condition, but be sure to call ahead due to a large group booking schedule.
— Joe
6 months ago
Incredibly rude person / manager. Played in 25 mph wind and 40 degree temps. Finished around 4 pm. While we lingered on the 18 the green, he.rode down and started yelling at us that the course was closed. When I asked what time it closes, he replied " an hour ago". Really? 3 pm! He just wanted to go home!
— Mike Fried
2 years ago
Course is in excellent condition. Staff is friendly & helpful; very accommodating. Fairways are well groomed. Greens rolled true. I owe a tip to the Starter😄
— Stacey Rose
9 months ago
Just a terrible experience. Took us like 4-6 hours to play 9 holes and had 8 people waiting at each tee box. Owners don’t care about there customers either, we said something and they said that couldn’t happen and had a terrible attitude. This was last week also the week they charged my friend more than they should have and then said he could use it towards his next round but the coming week he refused to let him use it and kicked us out for “lying” The money isn’t the problem the fact is they don’t care about their customers at all. $80+ for a round and the course isn’t even that good + yo…
— Aidan Maroney
9 months ago
The course's policy is to overpack the course which resulted in a long wait on at least 12 holes. Fairways were in good shape but the greens were not. Their rain out policy is ridiculous
— Mike Bifulco
7 months ago
Course is well groomed, great layout of the holes, 3 courses to play on- challenging holes. Really like the course
— Mary Mladek

Buy with the best & sell with confidence

Find a recommended local agent.

Search Our Agents