Private · 18 Holes

Gardiner's Bay Country Club

12 Dinah Rock Road, Shelter Island Heights, New York

PrivateMembership

18Holes

4.7★47 Reviews

Shelter Island Heights, NYLocation

1Listings

The Club

About Gardiner's Bay Country Club

Gardiner's Bay Country Club, established in 1896, is a private, member-owned club located on Shelter Island, New York. The club features a challenging 18-hole, par 70 course set over 160 pristine acres with stunning water views. Members enjoy a variety of golf and social events, a renowned Junior Golf School, and a newly renovated clubhouse...

Facilities

Club Amenities

Motor Cart

Pull Cart

Club Rental

Pro Shop

Golf Lessons

Driving Range

Putting Green

Chipping Green

Practice Bunker

Restaurant

Fine Dining

Casual Dining

Reception Hall

Clubhouse

Event Space

Real Estate

Listings at Gardiner's Bay Country Club

58 Country Club Dr

Shelter island, NY

$2,995,000

Membership

Joining Gardiner's Bay Country Club

Gardiner’s Bay Country Club offers various membership options, including Family, Couple, Single, Junior, and House memberships. Members enjoy access to the 18-hole golf course, dining facilities, and a calendar full of events. The club provides a welcoming environment with a focus on delivering a complete country club experience.

Membership Options

Ways to Join

Family

golf

Pricing on request

Includes husband, wife, and children under 18 years of age.

Four Endorsements

Couple

golf

Pricing on request

Includes husband and wife or parent and one child.

Four Endorsements

Single

golf

Pricing on request

For singles 18 years of age or older.

Four Endorsements

Junior

junior

$10/yrAnnual

For singles under 18 years of age, except if student exempt.

Two Endorsements
May not sponsor golf guests

House

social

Pricing on request

Includes restaurant privileges; no golf privileges.

Two Endorsements
May not sponsor golf guests

Fees are approximate and gathered from public sources — contact the club to confirm current pricing.

Reviews

What People Say

4.7/5

★★★★★

Google · 47 reviews

In summary

Gardiner's Bay Country Club is widely praised for its beautiful and well-maintained course, featuring challenging greens and scenic views of Gardiner's Bay. Visitors consistently commend the professional staff, excellent practice facilities, and outstanding food offerings. While the club is generally well-regarded, some mention that expenses are moderate.

★★★★★8 years ago

Beautiful course with challenging greens and fescue lined fairways. Practice facilities allow you to perfect every part of your game. The staff is very professional, and the pros will guide you to your best game. The food served in the clubhouse and at the grill rivals that of the finest restaurants in the region. My wife and I love it there.

— William Fraind

★★★★★Edited 2 years ago

G-Bay...is absolutely a wonderful golf course... with fantastic views of Gardner's Bay... Since 1992 watched this Golf Course involve into something very special... I also worked at Gardiners Bay Country Club and it wasn't for the job it was for the perks of being able to play the course...and in those years I became a much better golfer..⛳

— Bennett Karnis

★★★★★5 months ago