Shelter Island Country Club

We really hate this course. The greens are nice and that’s it. The tee boxes are uneven or don’t exist, and the fairways are covered in a combination of hard dirt and weeds. It has so much potential but it’s been completely neglected. It’s the worst course we’ve ever played and we play A LOT of public courses. The clubhouse is a great place to eat, the food and service are excellent.

This is historic Golf Course is very unique... seven out of the nine holes are blind to the green which makes it very difficult, it's not the length that get you here it's the angles the lies and the terrain... Everyday that you play this course, is a new adventure with a smile on your face...

Beautiful bunch spot. Turkey club is a delicious classic. The chicken sandwich is a winner too.

Great family owned restaurant. Good food nice atmosphere and friendly staff, highly recommend.

I had the pleasure of dining here for lunch and loved everything about it. I am in a wheelchair and everyone was so welcoming that it felt like family. The name fits the place to a tee because from any seat you can see practically for ever. Of course the most important thing about eating out is the food and it was delicious. I recommend you try it . You will be happy that you did.

Very hilly terrain, fairways are burnt and dusty. Tee boxes are choppy. Greens were slow but descent. They had checkered flags on top of hills to aim at because there were many blind shots to greens below. Not many level plains to hit from. Get what you pay for.

Beautiful course and many challenging holes because of the hills. By the way we call it Goat Hill.

Course is in disrepair to the point that it is virtually un-playable. Weeds, dust, sand and gravel abounds. Holes are not well designed (many shots over long baron hills into overgrown wooded areas). Staff often lurks in the bushes to scold you when you justifiably complain about the course's deplorable condition. Save your 37$ and go play in Sag Harbor instead.

Good 9 hole golf course, hilly and challenging at spots. Reasonably priced and never too crowded.

Wonderful place to visit. The staff and members are super nice.

horrible course bad grass highly recommend not playing here

Golf course is looking terrific for Early May !